Sonntag, 4. Mai 2014

My CAJ Topic in General Terms: Cyberwar

My CAJ topic in general terms
My CAJ topic of choice this semester is cyberwar and even though it is quite easy to define this topic, it is quite tricky to find reliable information on cyberwar on the internet, as, according to several science magazines and newspaper articles, there has not yet been a cyberattack that could be considered an act of war.

Generally cyberwar can be defined as a solely Internet-based conflict that takes place through electronic and not physical means. The means of a cyberwar are, of course, cyberattacks which do not only have the power to  disable websites and networks, but they can also disrupt important services, steal classified data or alter data and cripple entire financial systems. Recent developments in robotics, which led to the creation of unmanned vehicles or drones, would even allow cyberattacks of even greater scale if hackers succeed in infesting the sophisticated computer system of those drones.

Furthermore, it is important to know that in order to define cyberattacks as an act of war, it is essential that a government or state admits having played a role in those attacks. As this has, up to this point, never happened in history and as it is extremely difficult to trace cyberattacks back to its source, we cannot yet speak of the outbreak of a cyberwar.

When we talk about cyberwar, it is, however, indispensable to include the topics of cyber security and cyber technology, as both of them are inextricably linked to cyberattacks and therefore to cyberwar in general. 

Freitag, 2. Mai 2014

The role timing plays in cyberwar

http://www.nature.com/news/the-best-time-to-wage-cyberwar-1.14502
An important question when it comes to cyberwar is the question of timing. Should the hacker launch a cyberattack right at the moment he succeeds to enter the target’s computer or should he wait for an even better opportunity to attack? The problem in waiting too long is that the target could become aware of the intruder and fix the vulnerabilities in his computer system.
A new mathematical model that allows users to calculate the ideal timing of a surprise cyberattack has already been invented. An example for this is the Stuxnet worm, which infected an Iranian nuclear enrichment plant and went unnoticed for almost one and a half years. For Stuxnet a immediate attack was not the more rational approach.
If we compare cyberwar to convential warfare then a nation should wait patiently for the right occasion to use cyberweaponry. Terrorists, however, might think quite differently as this and just want to cause as much damage as possible at a random point of time. If the attackers are quite sure that the vulnerabilities in a security system are unlikely to be discovered and patched any time soon, then it would be quite reasonable for them to save their cyberweapons for a high-stake situation. At other times a zero-day cyberattack, in which the target has zero days to prepare for the attack, might be preferable. Stuxnet, for example which relied in four computer vulnerabilities being open at the same time, had to be dispatched as soon as possible.
The important question is whether the use of offensive cyber technology is productive or not. 

Mittwoch, 23. April 2014

Hackers in Cyberwar

Following my attempts to link cyberwar to robotics, I mean to link my CAJ topic to yet another one: Hacktivism. As you all can probably imagine hackers play a central role in the ongoing cyber conflicts and could play an important role in a future cyberwar.

The first example I want to mention is the cyber conflict that took place in 2012 between Israeli and Saudi Arabian hackers, sometimes even whole teams of hackers. During the ongoing cyber conflict, the credit card information of thousands of Israeli credit card holders was revealed on numerous websites. Those attacks lead to counterattacks, which lead to more counterattacks, causing increasing damage to innocent civilians. Hackers attempted to uncover the other hackers’ identities. Meanwhile the following attacks revealed the passwords and e-mails of thousands of people, official websites, including stock exchange sites, were targeted and taken down. Even though these attacks did not physically hurt the residents of both Israel and Saudi Arabia, numerous people suffered partly great financial losses.

As the cyber arms race continues, military thinkers and governmental advisers attempt to persuade the US government to recruit elite computer hackers. John Arquilla, a professor of defence analysis at the US Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, California, mentions that the brilliance of hacking experts is needed, as the US’ cyber technology is not as sophisticated as the technology its foes use to launch cyber attacks.

The main problem of this plan is that hackers and the government are not quite on good terms, mainly due to the lengthy jail terms for hacking. Arquilla estimates that there are only around 100 master hackers in the world, most of them situated in Asia and Russia. This is another reason why security agencies should exploit the talent and abilities of those genius hackers that are actually willing to work for them. He mentions that it is possible to stop militant organizations such as Al-Qaeda by disrupting their communications.

Arquilla stresses that he did not fear a full-scale cyberwar on the U.S, but instead multiple, small attacks which could lead to hundreds of billions of dollars in losses. Russia, China, even North Korea own highly sophisticated computer systems and know their strategic uses, but the average American system is completely helpless when he is used in some hacker’s botnet. With simply recruiting computer hackers, the U.S military could save millions of dollars and regain its position in the cyber race.

Sources:
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2012/jul/10/us-master-hackers-al-qaida
http://thenextweb.com/me/2012/01/18/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-ongoing-israeli-saudi-hacker-struggle/

Montag, 21. April 2014

Have Cyberwarfare and Drones Revolutionized Warfare?

As I already did in my lost blog post, I will try to concentrate on linking my CAJ topic to that of another student, concentrating once again on robotics. While doing some research on cyberwar linked to robotics, I came upon an article in the New York Times, informing about how robotics and cyberwarfare revolutionized warfare.
As proof of this assumption, the Battle of the Coral Sea, in which naval forces from Japan fought against the allied forces of Australia and the US, is mentioned. This was the first act of war in which carrier fought versus carrier, an inevitable result of the development of air, radio and radar technology. In military affairs this battle was considered a revolution. The revolution continued as nuclear and space weapons developed, but the most recent advancements in military capabilities include cyberwarfare and, of course, drones.
The authors of the article believe that the revolutions in military affairs of the 21st century will be dominated by advancements in software and hardware. They introduce drones as military weaponry able to increase the strike distance of the military, while simultaneously placing no lives at risk. A great problem of these drones, however, is the fact that basic jammers could easily disrupt their ability to function properly.
Just as drones, cybertechnology is a method that succeeds in extending the military’s reach while protecting lives from real harm. A great example for this type of attack is the Stuxnet worm, which I have already introduced in a precedent blog post. Cybertechnology allows hackers to gain access to computers all over the world, even if those don’t have direct Internet access. With the infrastructure currently in place, satellites and fiber cables, a good code could be an extremely effective weapon. This shows that cybersecurity becomes more and more important and should not be underestimated.
Cybertechology and unmanned vehicles both have one great advantage: they make it hard to identify the source of the attack. There is a risk that both technologies will make it easier to wage war, as there are not that many lives at stake any longer. In the future, man sitting in front of computers might be the soldiers of the upcoming wars.
According to the authors, the U.S is doing well in wanting to train new security and cyber professionals. They are worried though, that there is currently an inadequate number of leaders and experienced engineers that develop those future warriors. The authors stress the importance of both robotics and cybertechnology in future warfare, emphasizing that those two cannot be separated. The underlying problem remains, that the nation’s leaders might never know the moral, social and political consequences that the use of cybertechnology and unmanned vehicles in war could lead to.

Samstag, 19. April 2014

Drone Wars – When Cyber War becomes Real


In today’s post I will attempt to link my CAJ topic, cyberwar, to the CAJ topic of another student, namely robotics. I followed Bianca’s blog for quite a while and in one of her posts she wrote about drones and military robotics in general. I think that this topic can be linked quite well to cyberwar.
In the last few years an arms race has been going on, specializing in the creation of unmanned military equipment. In 2008, for example, about 12,000 ground robots were used in war. Congress has decided that by 2015, one third of all military ground vehicles are to be unmanned. Just as the with ground robots, Arial drone technology is advancing rapidly.

As I already mentioned in my last blog post, there has been a hype going in about cyberwar, even though the instances of cyberwar that have happened up to now point more to espionage and sabotage than to a real act of war. This would, however, change if these automated war machines were to be hacked and if a virus would suddenly change their intended target.

There have already been situations when military robots have acted erratic and acted upon by external sources such as electronic interferences. This has not yet posed a problem, but if this happened to armed robots, the consequences could be serious. An example for these disturbances are electronic jammers, often used in US vehicles to prevent improvised explosive device (IED attacks) can cause drones flying overhead to crash.

Already now many military, as well as civilian, computer systems are under constant attacks, so we can imagine that it is only a matter of time until automated military systems will be targeted as well. Up to know, luckily, no instances of automated systems being affected by viruses or attacked by hackers have been reported. If somebody would, however, succeed in injecting a code into these systems, allowing them to remote control military drones, a real cyberwar might ine day become reality.


Sources

Donnerstag, 17. April 2014

There won't be a cyberwar?

http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/new_scientist/2013/09/cyberwar_and_cyberattacks_it_s_really_espionage_subversion_or_sabotage.html

While researching my CAJ topic I recently found an article saying that cyberwar has never existed and probably never will. I generally do not like arguments that try to prove that something will never happen, for the simple reason that we can never say for sure that it won’t.

Anyways, the author of this article reasons that we cannot call the ongoing conflicts in the cyberworld a cyberwar for several reasons. According to him there are three features that are needed for cyber conflict to be considered cyberwar. First of all, the computer breach would need to be violent and able to hurt or kill people. Otherwise, so the author suggests, the attacks could not be described as an act of war. He further mentions that the act of cyberwar would need to be instrumental and compel the other to do something they would generally not even consider doing. Lastly, he mentions that there has to be a political motivation behind those attacks.

If those features define a cyberwar, we have not yet experienced one. Up to now there has been, according to the author, no injured person as a consequence of a cyberattack and there has been no nation yet that has taken credit for a cyberattack. As it is possible to cause an electricity blackout or interrupt a city’s freshwater supply or even to attack industrial control systems though, a cyberwar is definitely possible. Up to now, this has luckily never happened.

The author further explains that cyberespionage, a quite usual activity of cyberattacks, as well as cybersubervsion, the act of using social media to undermine authority, is not and cannot be considered cyberwar. In general he even says that the concept of cyberwar is misleading, as it is not violent, as a real war should be. The last comment he makes on cyberwar is, that the armed forces need to stay focused on fighting and winning the real wars of the future.

Of course I understand the reasoning used in this article and if it all of the author’s facts are true; it is possible that we have yet to experience a real cyberwar. We know, however, that cyberwar could happen in our world that is so dependent on technology. I personally think that one day cyberwar will happen, as it is the perfect opportunity for countries with little power and a small population to fight their opponents.

Mittwoch, 16. April 2014

The difficulties of tracing a cyber attack back to the attacker


What is true for the Stuxnet worm and the Estonian cyberwar is true for most cyber attacks, mostly the sophisticated ones among them.  In general, it is difficult to trace the attacks back to the original attacker and to find the real culprit behind the many attacks on another nation. The reason for this is quite simple. No intelligence service launching attacks on another nation would want to leave footprints that could lead back to them. They would want to deny their involvement in the stealing of data etc. and to proclaim innocence.

In addition to that, the more sophisticated opponents can easily hide their footprints by launching their attacks from a third country. And let’s be honest here: There are a lot of communication facilities around the world that could easily be hacked and used for an attack. China is one of those countries that are especially susceptible to being used as a platform for third-country-cyberattacks. The reason for this are its poorly secured networks, that hackers have no trouble taking over. China’s network is so vulnerable, because security practices are generally poor and because more than 90% of the software used in China is pirated. This makes it hard to obtain security updates and patches. More than three quarters of Chinese computers are generally found infected with malware. Just as vulnerable as the Chinese networks are American universities, as their large networks must be accessible at all times to hundreds, maybe thousands of students. This makes them especially vulnerable to misuse as a platform for cyber attacks on other American facilities.

In short, it can be said that just because an attack can be trace back to China, this does not necessarily mean that China is behind those attacks. The problem is that every nation has certain countries that it suspects of wanting to steal classified data or attack its industrial facilities. If an attack is traced back to one of those countries, the victim might not even think about investigating further for finding the real culprit.

Another aspect of cyber criminality that changed greatly in recent years is the availability of sophisticated hacking tools. In the past only well-established intelligence services had the power to launch cyberattacks. Nowadays, even a small virtual community of skilled cybercriminals could cause the same amount of damage. A large corporation might therefore just hire cybercriminals to steal certain data.


Cyber espionage is probably the form of attack that had benefitted most from the rise of the internet, as “information that once required physical access or recruitment of agents can now be downloaded from afar.” China is continuously copying the U.S military and even developed computer network operations capable of attacking U.S information centres and probably even infrastructure in the event of a conflict. Not only China, but also Russia, France, Israel and even North Korea own similar programs.
Even so, the main goal of all these attacks is to remain unnoticed and to have covered your digital footprints well enough in case the attacks are noticed by the victim. What matters is not really who is attacking, but how to secure data in general. This could be done by authenticating users, encrypting data, regular patching and of course by monitoring the systems for intrusions.